The Square–Cube Law
This is a lesson as teachers see it in OYLA Classroom. A free trial adds the answer key, printing, your own classes and Google Forms.
Teacher support
Lesson Goals
- describe how doubling a shape makes its flat surface grow four times and its solid body eight.
- explain why a doubled ant's legs, only four times stronger, cannot hold its eight-times-heavier body.
Main Question
If an ant grew twice as big in every direction, would it be twice as strong, or would something go wrong with its body?
Before Reading
Think of a time you watched an ant or another very small animal at work. What have you seen a tiny animal do that would be hard for a much bigger animal?
One heading in the article asks, Breaking the Rule? What rule do you think the article is talking about, and which animals might be the ones breaking it? (p. 7)
The heaviest animal on Earth lives in the ocean, not on land. What might the ocean give a huge animal that the land cannot?
Vocabulary
- scaling things up (p. 5)
- making something bigger while keeping the same shape
- surface (p. 5)
- the outside of a shape; the flat faces you can see and touch
- solid (p. 6)
- a shape that fills space in three directions, not flat like a drawing
- end-on (p. 7)
- looking at something from its end, the way you look into a straw
- strains (p. 8)
- pushes or pulls on something hard enough to risk harming it
Reading
Read pp. 4–9
Questions
The ant asks "Why four?" when the square was only doubled. Explain why doubling a flat square makes four little squares, not two. (p. 5)
The ant sums up the build on pp. 5–6: the flat square grew four times, and the solid cube grew eight. The article calls this rule the square-cube law. In your own words, what does the rule say about a shape's flat surface and its solid body as the shape grows? (p. 6)
The doubled ant expected to be eight times stronger, but it cannot lift the cube. Write two or three sentences explaining why its legs fell behind its body. (p. 7)
The article says the biggest dinosaurs had leg bones like straight tubes, stacked so the weight dropped through them in a straight line. You must hold up a heavy box with paper-towel tubes. Would you stand the tubes straight up under the box or lean them at a slant? Which way carries more, and why? (p. 8)
The ant decides being small is great, but the article says every size has a bill to pay. Tell a partner: What bill does a tiny animal pay, and why does the square-cube law send it that bill? Use: "A tiny animal has more... compared to its..., so..." (p. 9)
Exit Ticket
When the ant was made twice as big in every direction, how many times heavier did it become? (p. 7)
The article says real giants evolved features over millions of years to carry their weight. Describe one feature found in dinosaur bones and tell how it helped. (p. 8)
Why does the heaviest animal on Earth live in the ocean instead of on land? Use the square-cube law in your answer. (pp. 7–8)
Quiz · on the Quiz tab
Arrow keys, Page Up and Page Down turn the pages. Plus and minus zoom, or double-click a page to zoom in. F is full screen.
I can:
- tell how surface and body grow when a shape doubles.
- explain why a bigger ant's legs fall behind its weight.
Main Question
If an ant grew twice as big in every direction, would it be twice as strong, or would something go wrong with its body?
Before Reading
Think of a time you watched an ant or another very small animal at work. What have you seen a tiny animal do that would be hard for a much bigger animal?
One heading in the article asks, Breaking the Rule? What rule do you think the article is talking about, and which animals might be the ones breaking it? (p. 7)
The heaviest animal on Earth lives in the ocean, not on land. What might the ocean give a huge animal that the land cannot?
Vocabulary
- scaling things up (p. 5)
- making something bigger while keeping the same shape
- surface (p. 5)
- the outside of a shape; the flat faces you can see and touch
- solid (p. 6)
- a shape that fills space in three directions, not flat like a drawing
- end-on (p. 7)
- looking at something from its end, the way you look into a straw
- strains (p. 8)
- pushes or pulls on something hard enough to risk harming it
Reading
Read pp. 4–9
Questions
The ant asks "Why four?" when the square was only doubled. Explain why doubling a flat square makes four little squares, not two. (pp. 5–6)
The ant sums up the build on pp. 5–6: the flat square grew four times, and the solid cube grew eight. The article calls this rule the square-cube law. In your own words, what does the rule say about a shape's flat surface and its solid body as the shape grows? (pp. 5–6)
The doubled ant expected to be eight times stronger, but it cannot lift the cube. Write two or three sentences explaining why its legs fell behind its body. (p. 7)
The article says the biggest dinosaurs had leg bones like straight tubes, stacked so the weight dropped through them in a straight line. You must hold up a heavy box with paper-towel tubes. Would you stand the tubes straight up under the box or lean them at a slant? Which way carries more, and why? (pp. 7–8)
The ant decides being small is great, but the article says every size has a bill to pay. Tell a partner: What bill does a tiny animal pay, and why does the square-cube law send it that bill? Use: "A tiny animal has more... compared to its..., so..." (p. 9)
The answer key comes with a free trial.
Quiz
The ant asks for thicker legs. Why does the article say this would not really fix the problem? (p. 8)
- Thick legs would make the ant move too slowly to find food
- Thick legs would lose heat too fast in cold weather
- The legs would have to get so thick they took up most of the body
- Thick legs would be hollow inside and break too easily
Answer
What would happen if the ant were scaled up ten times? (p. 7)
- It would weigh 100 times as much and be 100 times stronger
- It would weigh 1,000 times as much but be only 100 times stronger
- It would weigh 1,000 times as much and be 1,000 times stronger
- It would weigh 10 times as much but be only 100 times stronger
Answer
Why can a tiny ant carry far more than a huge elephant can? (p. 9)
- It spends hardly any strength holding itself up
- Its legs are thicker compared to its body than an elephant's
- Its hollow bones make its whole body much lighter
- It loses heat faster, which gives its muscles more energy
Answer
Giants in films leap across rooftops. Why do the biggest real animals move carefully instead? (p. 8)
- Their heavy bodies lose too much heat when they run
- Their hollow bones would fill with water if they jumped
- They must save their strength for finding enough food
- A hard landing strains bones far more than standing still
Answer
Why do elephants have a hard time in hot weather? (p. 9)
- Their thick legs cannot bend so they cannot lie in the shade
- Their big bodies lose heat slowly
- They have more outside than inside compared to small animals
- They have to eat more often to stay cool
Answer
In the last part of the article, what does the author say about sizes in nature? (p. 9)
- Being small is always better because small animals are stronger
- Being big is better because big animals keep their heat longer
- There is no best size; each creature is built right for its own life
- Most animals would be stronger if they could grow bigger
Answer
The article says kids do better on the monkey bars than adults do. Explain why, using the square-cube law. (p. 9)
Answer
Exit Ticket
When the ant was made twice as big in every direction, how many times heavier did it become? (p. 7)
The article says real giants evolved features over millions of years to carry their weight. Describe one feature found in dinosaur bones and tell how it helped. (p. 8)
Why does the heaviest animal on Earth live in the ocean instead of on land? Use the square-cube law in your answer. (pp. 7–8)
Recall (DOK 1)
When you built a cube twice as big out of small cubes, how many small cubes did it take?
A flat square has two directions to grow in. What three directions does a solid cube have?
According to the article, where does a leg's strength come from?
Skills and concepts (DOK 2)
Compare Galileo's thick giant bone with how real giants solved the weight problem. How are the two answers different?
The ant first said that at elephant size it would be the strongest animal on Earth. Use two pieces of evidence from the article to argue whether it was right.
Sort the giants' four features into two groups: ones that make the body lighter or hold up its weight, and ones that change how or where the animal lives.
NGSS performance expectations
4-LS1-1
- Engaging in Argument from Evidence
- LS1.A: Structure and Function
- Systems and System Models
3-LS4-3
- LS4.C: Adaptation
Reading standards (Common Core)
RI.3.1
Ask and answer questions to demonstrate understanding of a text, referring explicitly to the text as the basis for the answers.RI.3.2
Determine the main idea of a text; recount the key details and explain how they support the main idea.RI.3.3
Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect.W.4.1
Write opinion pieces on topics or texts, supporting a point of view with reasons and information.W.3.1
Write opinion pieces on topics or texts, supporting a point of view with reasons.W.3.2
Write informative/explanatory texts to examine a topic and convey ideas and information clearly.SL.3.4
Report on a topic or text, tell a story, or recount an experience with appropriate facts and relevant, descriptive details, speaking clearly at an understandable pace.RI.4.3
Explain events, procedures, ideas, or concepts in a historical, scientific, or technical text, including what happened and why, based on specific information in the text.RI.5.3
Explain the relationships or interactions between two or more individuals, events, ideas, or concepts in a historical, scientific, or technical text based on specific information in the text.RI.3.4
Determine the meaning of general academic and domain-specific words and phrases in a text relevant to a grade 3 topic or subject area.RI.4.4
Determine the meaning of general academic and domain-specific words or phrases in a text relevant to a grade 4 topic or subject area.RI.5.4
Determine the meaning of general academic and domain-specific words and phrases in a text relevant to a grade 5 topic or subject area.RI.4.5
Describe the overall structure (e.g., chronology, comparison, cause/effect, problem/solution) of events, ideas, concepts, or information in a text or part of a text.
Connects to other subjects
Science & Society
3-LS4-3 · Interdependence of Science, Engineering, and Technology